Wednesday, September 15, 2010

California Preemption Decison with Unclaimed Property Implications

A recent opinion of the California Court of Appeal relating to the preemption of a California consumer protection statute has implications for state unclaimed property laws.  In Tanen v. Southwest Airlines, the court ruled that state-law claims relating to the redemption of Southwest "travel certificates" were preempted by the federal Airline Deregulation Act ("ADA").  Although the Tanen case did not specifically deal with the California Unclaimed Property Act, the court's preemption rationale is likewise applicable to the unclaimed property laws of those states who seek to take possession of unused airline tickets.  A brief summary of Tanen is as follows:

According to the complaint, Tanen purchased a $100 travel certificate from Southwest in February of 2005.  Southwest's travel certificates are redeemable toward the purchase of an airline ticket, food and drinks on flights, and Southwest vacation packages.  The travel certificate order form indicated that "[a]ll gift certificates expire one year from the date of issue and will not be extended unless prohibited by law."  Tanen's travel certificate expired in February of 2006, and he brought suit against Southwest in May of 2006.  Tanen alleged, among other things, that the one year expiration date violated Section 1749.5 of the California Civil Code, which generally prohibits the imposition of expiration dates on gift certificates and related items.

In opposition to the suit, Southwest argued that Tanen's claims were preempted by the Airline Deregulation Act, which preempts state laws relating to the "price[s], route[s] or service[s] of an air carrier."  The lower court ruled that because the travel certificates could be redeemed for tickets, the were "at the heart of what the ADA sought to preempt," and dismissed the complaint.  On appeal, the Second District Court of Appeal affirmed.  The court concluded that Section 1749.5 related to airline "services," and was thus preempted, because enforcement of the prohibition against expiration dates would have the effect of requiring airlines "to offer travel certificates that are redeemable at any time, rather than permit them to offer travel certificates with varying expiration dates."  The court also noted that its decision was consistent with other cases in which courts concluded that state consumer protection laws could not prevent airlines from offering nonrefundable tickets.  Accordingly, the court affirmed the dismissal of the complaint, and awarded Southwest appeal costs.

Though the Tanen case did not address California's unclaimed property laws, the court's logic is no less applicable to state attempts to bring unused airline tickets within the scope of their unclaimed property laws.  Although unused airline tickets are expressly exempt in some states (such as Alaska), there are numerous states whose unclaimed property acts expressly apply to such items (e.g., Mississippi, Oklahoma, Utah, Colorado, and Oregon).  Much the same as enforcement of the California consumer protection law was preempted because its enforcement would have the effect of requiring airlines to offer a product that they did not (non-expiring gift certificates), the application of state unclaimed property laws would likewise require airlines to offer airline tickets that are valid in perpetuity.  As a practical matter, I don't know if any airline actually escheats unused airline tickets, or whether the states with such laws seek to enforce the requirement.  If so, it will be interesting to see if airlines seek to use the Tanen decision to avoid escheating these items in the future.


  1. Nice blog.Thanks admin for sharing this information.Aviation courses can be one of the perfect way to initiate a successful career . There are various ‪‎airline‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬ courses available.After completing my‪ ‎course‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬ in ‪‎aviation‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬ i hope that my career will be good.‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬
    Aviation academy in chennai | Aviation Courses in chennai

  2. Discover how to book international flights for $100 instead of $1,000 using Travel Hacking.

  3. Siempre habrá una razón por la cual podrán comprar Bolsas Michael Kors Precios de los minoristas en línea. Los compradores de hoy que estén interesados en comprar Michael Kors Rebajas podrán descubrir cómo pueden obtener los mejores resultados que siempre quisieron simplemente haciendo ruido con lo mejor de Bolsos Michael Kors Outlet que ofrecen más allá de precios asequibles.

    Dessutom med så många alternativ att välja mellan, har det blivit praktiskt taget omöjligt för köpare att ta reda på hur de kan köpa Designer Michael Kors Väska Rea online utan att behöva investera för mycket pengar eller tid i scouting den lokala marknaden som annars skulle tyckas omöjligt att göra först . En riktig äkta Michael Kors Rea skulle kunna ge dig tillbaka tusentals dollar och det är något som de flesta inte har råd med. Du kan faktiskt köpa Michael Kors Plånbok online.

    Maintenant, la question se pose de savoir si vous pouvez réellement trouver en ligne authentique Longchamp Soldes bon marché qui sont vraiment authentiques et la réponse est oui, vous pouvez! Un des sites les mieux notés et les plus populaires pour localiser le Sac A Main Longchamp en ligne parfait pour votre collection personnelle est eBay. Rappelez-vous, juste parce que vous êtes en mesure de magasiner en ligne Sac À Main Longchamp sur eBay à des prix incroyablement bas ne signifie pas qu'ils sont faux ou de qualité bon marché.

  4. Algunas tiendas de Internet que venden bolsos michael kors baratos tienen los estilos más novedosos y más recientes que Coach tiene para ofrecer. bolsos michael kors baratos son los líderes en su mercado y lo han sido desde hace algún tiempo. Dado que bolsas michael kors outlet es tan alcanzable debido a sus precios más bajos, se ha convertido en el Bolsos Michael Kors Baratos más popular hasta la fecha.(Fuente

    Om du letar efter Michael Kors Väska Rea och vill betala ett visst pris, är det bästa sättet att gå till det via auktionswebbplatser. Skulle du bara ge upp att äga en autentisk Michael Kors Väska helt och hållet eftersom du vet att din budget inte tillåter det? Eller skulle du söka på Internet för den Väskor Michael Kors Rea i hopp om att du hittar det för några dollar mindre? Om din dröm är att äga michael kors väska rea, gör dina drömmar giltiga genom att gå online och hitta den michael kors plånbok som du vill ha.(Källa frå

    La première étape pour obtenir Longchamp Soldes Destockage à prix réduit consiste à aller en ligne. La deuxième étape consisterait à rechercher des sites proposant des Longchamp Soldes dans votre budget d'achat. Je connais un endroit formidable qui propose des chaussures, des accessoires et des mercedes longchamp pour non seulement quelques dollars de moins que le commerce de détail, mais des centaines de moins. La bonne solution serait de chercher ailleurs ce sac longchamp solde en particulier et bien d’autres jusqu’à ce que vous l’obteniez et de ne jamais abandonner vos rêves.(Source à partir

  5. The article is very interesting. And I also want to share articles about health, I'm sure this will be useful. Read and share it. Thank you very much :)

    Manfaat Walatra Spirulina Untuk Wajah
    Solusi Tepat Pengobatan Kanker Nasofaring
    Manfaat QnC Jelly Gamat


  6. Get daily updates directly to your inboxSubscribeSee our Cosplay Mask privacy noticeMore newslettersAlternatively, contact the Cheap Full Lace Wigs NHS 111 non emergency number. The service is set up to advise you on the care you need. Staff can also assist Human Hair Wigs with arranging an out of hours Cheap Human Hair Lace Front Wigs appointment.What about walk in centres? Many walk in centres will be open as normal on Christmas Day, Boxing Day and New Year's Day.It is worth calling and checking the opening times before you head there.Walk in centres are for urgent care if you can't wait for a GP appointment.They can help with illnesses including ear/nose/throat symptoms, minor cuts and bruises, sprains and strains, abdominal pain, insect and animal bites, rashes and urinary tract infections.NHS guidelines suggest you call their non emergency 111 number first.WALK IN CENTRE OPENING TIMESWalk in centre at Manchester Royal Infirmary Open 8am until 10pm every day over the Christmas holiday and New YearCity Designer Phone Cases Health Walk In Centre, Market Street Christmas Eve open 8am to 8pm; Christmas Design Your Own Shirt Day open 8am to 8pm; Boxing Day open 8am to 8pm; New Year's Eve open 8am to 8pm; New Year'S Day open 8am to pm.

  7. There's also the University of Texas Tower (23rd Street at Guadalupe), which was built in 1936 and is the pride of the University of Texas at Austin. It's 27 stories high just a little bit taller than the State Capitol, and it lights up in burnt orange every time there's a UT victory. When UT won the Rose Bowl against football powerhouse the University of Southern California in 2005, the tower glowed burnt orange for nearly two weeks in celebration. (Michael Kors Guitar Strap Mini Crossbody Bag Black)

    He has been charged with home invasion causing injury, aggravated battery/strangulation and criminal damage to property. 31, 2018" > >Aurora police looking for information after vehicle shot on Fulton StreetAurora police are looking for information after a vehicle was shot at Thursday. In the 900 block of Fulton Street when a newer black sedan drove up, stopped and an occupant got out of the. (Michael Kors Crossbody Bag Jet Set Black)

    Peace, good is coming disturbia ringtone in movie. Maybe theyre appalling track record store in my life ringtone together theyll blame me started. Only woz how does not nearly 2, samsung hue ringtones if it in to comment string? Ponytail boy to love the glory of love ringtone. (Michael Kors Mott Belt Bag Black)

    Coach Outlet Bags Real, 3. Your Right to Terminate the License. With the exception of Interactive Content, you may remove or modify Content that you post on the Site. Ehlinger 2 Touchdown Passes Lead Texas Over No. 22 USC 37 14Sam Ehlinger passed for two touchdowns, Anthony Wheeler returned a blocked field goal 46 yards for a score and Texas beat No. 22 Southern California 37 14 on Saturday night to give second year coach Tom Herman his biggest win in burnt orange.. (Black Michael Kors Bag Tj Maxx)

  8. Ray Ban Round Sunglasses with nearly all mental disorder diagnoses, the symptoms Real Yeezy Shoes of Discount Jordan Shoes Wholesale manic Ray Ban Sunglass Hut depression must cause clinically Michael Kors Bags Sale significant distress or impairment Coach Bags On Sale Online in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.This post has been updated for DSM 5criteria.For more information:Bipolar Screening TestBipolar QuizWhat is bipolar depression?Treatment MK Outlet of Ray Ban Prescription Sunglasses Bipolar DisorderDSM 5 Codes for Bipolar DisorderReferencesAmerican Psychiatric Association. (2013) Coach Outlet Store Online.