Monday, April 8, 2013

North Dakota Gets "Reasonable" About Third-Party Unclaimed Property Audits

North Dakota's Governor signed Senate Bill 2058 into law on March 15th.  In addition to giving the state tax commissioner authority to share personally-identifying information with the state's unclaimed property division it also sets forth that a new provision concerning audits. 

While the North Dakota Unclaimed Property Act (like most state laws based on one of the uniform acts) provides that the state may commence an unclaimed property audit regardless of whether the holder believes it has unclaimed property, the new law clarifies that the state many not "contract for an examination" (i.e., with a private auditing firm) unless the state has "reasonable cause to believe" that a person has failed to comply with the act.

This distinction, while minor, is a welcome addition to the precepts of unclaimed property law enforcement.  In the context of a privately-run examination -- even where the holder has little or nothing to report -- the time, effort, and resources necessary to respond to an audit is tremendous.  Indeed, in some instances, the private auditors may be working on a contingent fee (meaning, they get paid a portion of what they find) and thus have a financial interest in making sure that the audit result is a large amount, regardless of whether that is the right amount.  While the contingent fee nature of the audit should, in theory, protect a compliant holder because the auditor will not want to waste (unpaid) time trying to squeeze blood from a stone, that theory does not hold up to practice.  In reality, some contract auditing firms perform "their" audit by making burdensome information demands upon the holder, selecting items at random to be "tested" from that information, then demanding the holder "prove" that the randomly selected items are not unclaimed property.  Adding insult to injury, should the holder push back on a particularly burdensome, ill-conceived, or irrelevant demand, the auditing firm responds by threatening to inform the contracting states that the holder is being "uncooperative." 

For a variety of reasons (not the least of which is that state employed auditors do not get a cut of what they find) state-run unclaimed property audits tend to be less disruptive and less adversarial.  Accordingly, North Dakota's decision to limit the contract auditors to places where there is "reasonable cause" to believe that noncompliance exists is a welcome step for those holders who are in compliance. 


  1. Didn't prior law bar contract audits entirely?

  2. No matter what type of Michael Kors Bags Outlet each individual got, they all had one thing in common. We all know that getting something on sale is like winning a mini lottery, but to find a name brand handbag like Michael Kors Black Friday Sale for instance, discounted is like a slice of heaven on earth. I have personally attacked my husband with hugs and kisses when finding Official Coach Outlet Online at discounted prices.

    Michael Kors Factory Outlet stores can be found in malls all over. MK Outlet and other Coach merchandise can also be found in some boutiques. Inspired by the same material baseball gloves are made from, these Coach Bags On Sale Online are versatile and stylish. Since it's conception, the Michael Kors Handbags Outlet has been produced into a variety of designs, colors, shapes, and styles that have won top pick of millions of women the world over.

    New Michael Kors Bags are the most sought after handbag. Since Coach Outlet Online is one of the most recognized name brands in the world of fashion, you will find A-list celebrities down to small girls wearing them.

    tags:Coach Outlet|Coach Bags Factory Outlet|Coach Purses Outlet