Wednesday, April 3, 2019

Is "True Escheat" The Future of Unclaimed Property?

Nevada is considering a bill "providing that all property rights and legal title to, and ownership of" of U.S. savings bonds would "vest in this State" after three years. After that three year period, the state could choose to pay the proceeds to the rightful owner of the bond, but the decision to do so would be left to the state's discretion. West Virginia is considering similar legislation, A law proposed in Hawaii goes even further providing that all unclaimed property with a value of $100 or less shall immediately "escheat to the State and be transferred to the general fund."

These are just a few examples of a new (and for unclaimed property owners, troubling) trend in unclaimed property legislation -- a shift from "custodial" escheat laws to "true" escheat laws.
Currently, most state unclaimed property laws are "custodial" in nature -- meaning that the state takes possession of the unclaimed property on the rightful owner's behalf, but the state never actually takes "title" (i.e., ownership). Instead, the state holds the property in trust, and the rightful owner can always claim the property from the state when he or she becomes aware of it. To be sure, the state may use those monies for schools, roads, or other budgetary purposes in the interim, but the rightful owner retains the right to get his or her money or property back.

The rationale for such "custodial" escheat laws is reasonably straightforward: given that the rightful owner is not in possession, someone is going to have the "free" use of the money. Better that it be the state for the use of all citizens than a private company. In the custodial paradigm, the owner theoretically is no worse off by the state, rather than a company, holding his or her property (at least if the property is cash, and not securities).

In a "true" escheat system, the state ultimately acquires not only custody of the property, but ownership. As a result, the rights of the original owner are deemed "cut off." As explained by 18th Century English jurist William Blackstone in his Commentaries on the Laws of England, the rationale for "true" escheat laws is that all property rights were ultimately derived from the sovereign: "The grand and fundamental maxim of all feudal tenure is this; that all lands were originally granted out by the sovereign, and are therefore holden, either mediately or immediately, of the crown." Accordingly, where something happens to the current owner, the property reverts back to the sovereign.

While this rule may still make sense for "real property" (i.e., land) with the sovereign being the state, it is not for most "intangible" property. A share of stock you purchase from an issuer, a CD you deposit at a bank, a payroll check -- none of these items "originated" with the state. The potential for true escheat laws, along with the ever expanding scope of unclaimed property laws, and the apparently inexorable process of making dormancy periods shorter and shorter, could very well have a significant and negative impact on the owners of unclaimed property.

While the current proposals appear to be modest (just a single property type here, a $100 limit there) it is not hard to imagine such laws being expanded. Owners should be wary.

3 comments:

  1. Assistant Crown attorney John Skoropada said Payne convinced the man to use his account at the Bank of Montreal to cash her cheque for her, only to see it bounce Cheap Jordans For Sale at the end Yeezy Boost 350 Cheap of the clearance period. Payne lawyer, Black And Yellow Jordan 1 John Dillon, told Justice Larry O that his client, with the help of her mother and other family, has since been able to put together full restitution. He informed the judge those funds were already in Yeezy Boost For Sale his law practice trust account ready to be paid out.

    With the freeways so wide open right now, I bet you have Yeezy Boost 350 Cheap looked at the speedometer and were shocked how fast you were going. Washington State Yeezys For Sale Patrol has noticed a jump in speeding too. While heading to the office, and have been shocked to see my speed approaching Yeezy Boost 350 Black 80 miles Jordan 1 Black And White an hour on I 5 through Snohomish and King counties.

    I have liked to score 30 goals a year and play 800 NHL games, yeah, but it wasn the case and I fortunate to have played as many pro games as Purple And White Jordans I did, he said. Complaints on what I did or how I did it. First NHL game was as an Oiler. Neville feigns humility about being David Beckham bag man, but for the best part of a decade he was one of the most proactive right backs in Europe and unchallenged at club and international level.Read MoreExclusive: United make decision on Fosu Mensah futureNeville had the medals but not the international recognition of Lilian Thuram, a World Cup and European Championship winner with the great France side at the turn of the century, the exoticism of another World Cup winner, Cafu, or the unflustered magnificence of Javier Zanetti.Trent Alexander Arnold is fortunate in that the Premier League has unrivalled worldwide exposure and he has emerged in the social media era. Alexander Arnold has a fervent following among Liverpudlians that filters through to certain members of the press who Black And White Jordans only refer to him as He has raised the bar for attack minded full backs though rarely held to account for flaky defending exploited by Wolves. Watford and Atletico Madrid this calendar year alone.Read MoreLuke Shaw is in a similar situation to Ryan Giggs at UnitedNeville, another local hero, was more unabashed in flaunting his attachment to United and openly admitted he Scousers in his early 20s..

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jordan Shoes For Sale Cheap individual, cultural and practical barriers to participation were identified.

    Are pleased that the review confirmed that there are no financial irregularities or improprieties. The report highlighted that our spending is fully aligned with that of other Michael Kors Bags Sale metro school jurisdictions and that we have strong financial Coach Outlet Store Online processes and controls. 2020 Jordan Release Dates The review also found that we have very efficient operations, especially in the area of operations and maintenance.

    ReplyDelete